Research · methodology note · Nov 16, 2026
The energy contract-month mismatch: what we caught and removed
The energy scorecard flags a crude-oil contract when Kalshi's price diverges from an independent fair value. Kalshi's WTI markets settle on a specific futures month, named in each market's rules (for example, a mid-November settle references the January contract). Our fair value was anchored to the continuous front-month future (CL=F) instead. In the days before a futures contract expires, Kalshi rolls its settlement reference to the next month while the front month has not, so a front-month fair was compared against a back-month contract. The gap between the two months, the calendar spread, then showed up as a divergence that was not real.
How we know it was the contract, not the market
Each stored snapshot carries both ladders: the Kalshi prices and the Scopes fair value, across every strike. If the two priced the same contract their implied medians would coincide. On the affected days they differed by about a dollar to a dollar and a half, the size of the WTI calendar spread at the time, with the whole ladder shifted by the same amount. A uniform level shift of that size is two different contract months being compared, not a disagreement about the odds.
What we found, and removed
We re-anchored every resolved energy flag to the futures month its Kalshi contract actually settles on and re-checked which side the fair value backed. Of 138 resolved flags, 69 were computed during a month mismatch, but for 61 of those the side the fair backed did not change, so their scored result stands. For 8 flags the correct anchoring flipped the side: all 8 fell in the August roll window, and all 8 had been scored correct only because the front-month bias pushed the fair above the market. Corrected, the divergence that triggered each flag largely disappears and the fair backs the other side. Because the comparison was against the wrong contract, those 8 are withheld rather than counted.
| Resolved energy flags reviewed | 138 |
| Computed during a month mismatch (>= $0.50 median gap) | 69 |
| Scored side flipped by correct anchoring (withheld) | 8 |
| Energy record before / after | 43 of 138 (31%) → 35 of 130 (27%) |
The correction cuts against us: it lowers the energy record rather than raising it. The mismatch was not hurting the scorecard, it was quietly flattering it with eight calls that correct anchoring turns into non-divergences or losses. We publish it the same way regardless.
What we changed
Going forward the fair value is anchored to the futures month each Kalshi market settles on, not the front month. The scorecard is append-only, so we do not delete or rewrite a flag once recorded: the 8 affected flags remain in the underlying record, marked not-scored, so the correction is auditable rather than hidden. Energy flags are also withheld near settlement under the near-settlement rule. The live energy scorecard now reflects only flags measured against the settlement contract month.
Cite this study
Free to cite with attribution to Scopes. For the citation format, boilerplate, and media contact, see Press & citation.